Is Life Insurance Better Than Traditional Investing?

PUBLISHED Oct 31, 2022, 1:37:11 PM        SHARE

imgBest Interest Blog

A client at work recently asked:

There are lots of social media videos where “experts” say life insurance is a superior investment to 401(k) and IRA accounts. Sounds weird to me, but you guys are the experts – what are your thoughts?

He’s right. Social media – especially TikTok – is littered with pro-insurance videos. Not coincidentally, those videos are created by insurance agents who make fat commissions when they sell policies.

Show me the incentives, I’ll show you the outcome.

Charlie Munger

I don’t use TikTok, so I Google’d, “tiktok insurance vs. 401k videos.” This is the first one I found. It doesn’t disappoint.

TikTok @deb.younkin

Math doesn’t lie. So her argument seems…convincing! Right?

But people do lie. And if a person decides to use dishonest numbers at the beginning of an analysis, they’ll get a dishonest result. Garbage in, garbage out.

I think it’s more likely this lady is regurgitating sales pitches she learned at insurance school. Not outright lying, per se, but repeating the lies her company told her.

If you’re curious about the lies, a few of them are:

  • She assumes no 401(k) match, despite 98% of 401(k) plans offering a match.
  • She assumes the 401(k) investment stops growing completely at retirement. Using her previous assumption of 7% annual growth, she’s neglecting ~$380,000 of post-retirement growth. Seems important, no?
  • How is the IUL (that’s indexed universal life) policy growing at 7% per year, despite the steep investment fees of ~3% per year?
  • And finally, how can a policy worth $523,000 afford to disburse $67,000 per year (or 12.8% of its original value) forever? Especially when it’s only growing, supposedly, at 7% per year? Because of loans and infinite banking, Jesse! Yeahhhh. We’ll get into that later.

And the lies keep coming. When you dig into a life insurance policy (which we frequently do for our clients), the lies compound. The most frequent are:

  • Cherry-picking the timeframe of comparison. If you compare life insurance against the S&P 500 from 2000 to 2010, I’m sure life insurance will win. If you expand that timeframe beyond the worst decade in stock market history, the result will change.
  • Ignoring their own fees. The fees on the investment portion of life insurance products often surpass 2% per year. This is astoundingly high.
  • It’s insurance though, right? Why are insurance products being sold as investments? Why co-mingle? Seriously. Why? (answer: to make it more enticing and sell more policies). And at the end of the day, how good is the actual insurance portion of the product? (answer: not that good). Rather than buy two pieces of junk co-mingled into one product, just separate them!
  • Misrepresenting traditional investment returns. Example: not including dividend reinvestment when comparing against the S&P 500. Elementary stuff that any investment professional should know better about.

When you correct the lies and add them up, the result is disgusting.

Over a 30-year timeline of $500 monthly payments (just like in the video above), an IUL policy indexed to the S&P 500 would have a cash value of ~$350,000.

If that $500 was invested in a simple, taxable investing account instead, the account would be worth $1.10 million. If in a 401(k) with a match, you’d have well over $2 million.

But Jesse – Borrow Against the Policy!

In that terrible TikTok video above, there was a “secret sauce” about borrowing against the insurance policy. Some people call this “infinite banking” or “creating your own bank” or “being your bank,” etc.

In other words: don’t touch the policy itself. Borrow money, and use the policy as collateral.

This idea isn’t new. Financial leverage is an age-old idea. But let’s recall the account values from above. Would you rather:

  • Borrow against a $350,000 life insurance policy (P.S. – you get charged interest for doing so), or…
  • Withdraw funds from a $1.1 million account?

Call me crazy, but I’d rather just have the $1.1 million, or 3x more money than the life insurance policy. I don’t have to borrow against it. I can just…spend it.

But the Tax Benefits?!

A common insurance sales tactic relates to the tax benefits of life insurance. Guess what? This is (mostly) a lie.

When does life insurance provide a large tax benefit? The following must be true:

  • Your 401(k) and IRA accounts are already maxed out yearly.
  • Your estate will surpass the Federal estate tax threshold: $12.06 million for individuals and $22.12 million for couples.
  • If this sounds like you, a life insurance policy may provide you a tax benefit.

If you haven’t maxed out your 401(k) or IRA, then you don’t need an insurance policy masquerading as an investment to provide you tax benefits. The tax advantages of 401(k) and IRA accounts are ALWAYS equivalent or superior to those of insurance/investment policies.

If you have more than $12.06 million or $22.12 million as a couple, then you can/should consider if a life insurance policy would provide you a tax benefit. Since you’ve got a fair chunk of change, I’d consult an independent professional to help you with that analysis. Not TikTok. Nor a blog like this one. Just sayin’…

If you need life insurance – you know, the real product behind insurance policies – buy a term policy.

Why Then? Why?!

Why, then, do so many TikTok videos espouse the investment benefits of life insurance?

Show me the incentives, I’ll show you the outcome.

Charlie Munger

Because insurance agents typically receive a commission equivalent to 80%-100% of the first year’s insurance premiums. Insurance agents have families to feed. They’ve got to sell policies. They have to convince you to buy.

The pitches that we debunked above sound great. They convince people to buy life insurance. It does not equate to a wise purchase. It’s that simple. I don’t begrudge any insurance agent, with mouths to feed, for pitching a bad product. I do begrudge their management who ought to know better, but that’s for another blog post.

The real math shows how terrible an “investment” whole life, indexed life, or other co-mingled life insurance policies really are.

Thank you for reading! If you enjoyed this article, Subscribe to get future articles emailed to your inbox.


Want to learn more about The Best Interest’s back story? Read here

Originally Posted on BestInterest.blog

Sound investments
don't happen alone

Find your crew, build teams, compete in VS MODE, and identify investment trends in our evergrowing investment ecosystem. You aren't on an island anymore, and our community is here to help you make informed decisions in a complex world.

More Reads
How to Value Utility Stocks

Stable, well-run utilities can be predictable to value. We’ll walk through the steps you need to do to find the intrinsic value of a utility

Risk Rated Funds Are Broken

I have a piece being published in CityWire this week which I think might make some waves. Its message is that passive and active risk rated funds, in which tens if not hundreds of billions are invested worldwide, are broken and could remain so for years. The reason? High inflation.

Recent Stock Purchase October 2022

As you know by now I make a stock purchase every single month no matter what is going on in the world and despite the doom and gloom headlines. Perhaps I am naive or more of an optimist that we will get through these dark financial times somehow. Either way, I have been busy buying up some stock this month and was happy to put some fresh and recycled capital to work to try and recoup some of my lost dividend income courtesy of the numerous cuts bestowed upon my portfolio in recent years.

October 2022 Stock Considerations

A new trading month is about the begin and boy do we have a seemingly endless crop of stocks that are becoming fair valued to undervalued. The reality of the day is that we’ll continue to see stock prices continue to come down as interest rates rise. No reason to believe interest rates will stop climbing anytime soon.

Earnings and Cash Flows: A Primer on Free Cash Flow

It is never pleasant to be in the midst of a market correction, but a market correction does operate as a cleanser for excesses that enter into even the most disciplined investors' playbooks in the good times. This correction has been no exception, as the threat of losing investment capital has focused the minds of investors, and led many to reexamine practices adopted during the last decade. In particular, there has been more talk of earnings than of revenue or user growth this year, and the notion of cashflows driving value seems to be back in vogue.

Deleveraging to Build Back Better

Hey everyone This is a post that is a long time running and one that I actually didn’t really want to sit down and write. For the first time since we started investing, I have actually turned bearish. We decided to sell off some stock to pay off our home equity line of credit completely. This will definitely destroy our passive income at the moment but I feel like its a good move being debt free once again.

30 Frugal Living Tips to Build a Fortune

You can live a rich life by spending less… Frugal living doesn’t mean skimping on what’s valuable. Instead, it’s a way to maximize value in your life. This is the big difference with being cheap… Cheapskates try to find the lowest price tag on everything. As a result, they often buy goods that don’t last long.

5 Funeral Home Stocks and Death Care Trends

There are two certainties in life… death and taxes. Most people plan for taxes each year but few plan their funeral. It’s a tough topic to discuss but your family will be relieved that you had it planned. Losing a loved one is difficult and when you’re emotionally fragile and grief-stricken, planning a funeral is even harder. Funeral homes know this. They’re for-profit companies, and their industry is booming thanks to the world’s growing (and grieving) population.

Current Open Options Trades

As described in my goals post here, my focus has changed to only choosing “Quality” companies for my options trades. Chasing premium is nice when it works, but as you will see below, I have been left with some companies that I would rather not own.

September 2022 Dividend Growth Watchlist

As I described in my post here about my passive income strategy, I will be focusing on 3 key areas 1. Dividends 2. Options 3. Mortgage The first 2 parts all involve the stock market and my main criteria is to focus on quality companies as much as possible. During the last 2 years I have been stuck with some real humdingers, either by chasing yield or chasing premium.

Dominion Stock Forecast - Dominion Stock Dividend

Dominion Stock Forecast for the upcoming quarters is optimistic. Why is Dominion Energy stock dropping? Let's explore Dominion Stock Dividend!

Fundraising For Cryptocurrency Projects: Here’s Everything You Need to Know

Thinking of raising funds for your crypto project? Find out how.

Best Solana NFTs To Buy in 2022

Looking for the best Solana NFTs in 2022? Find out in this article.

Five Below stock growth, earning report, buy or sell, and news

Five Below Inc., often known as fiVe BEL°W in abbreviated form. It is a chain of specialist discount stores in the United States. Learn more!

How to Improve Credit Score to Get a Mortgage

Make Sure the Dream of Home Ownership is in Your Grasp!

The Three Main Pillars of Trading / Investing

A Broad Overview of Where to Start

Utility Stocks in a Recession- Are Utility Stocks a Good Buy Now?

Utility stocks in a recession perform really well. So are utility stocks a good buy now when inflation is higher? Let's discover it!

SRE Stock Forecast and the Latest Earnings Report

SRE stock forecast is very impressive as many analysts are expecting this stock to outperform the market. Let's learn how!

The Debt Avalanche Method

This Method Can Help Get You Debt-Free Faster!

Resources for Publishers
Resources for New Investors
Boosted with BossCoin